Choosing the best Christmas trees

By Ron Wolford, Extension Educator Urban Gardening/Environment

University of Illinois Extension

Whether you buy a Christmas tree from a lot or a farm, you usually have a number of Christmas tree varieties to choose from. Knowing a little bit about Christmas tree needle retention, fragrance and color can help you to choose that "perfect" tree, said a University of Illinois Extension horticulture educator.

Ron Wolford provided brief sketches of Christmas tree varieties to help consumers.

Balsam Fir - Abies balsamea - three-fourth to one and one-half inches short, flat, long-lasting needles that are rounded at the tip; nice, dark green color with silvery cast and fragrant. Named for the balsam or resin found in blisters on bark. Resin is used to make microscope slides and was sold like chewing gum; used to treat wounds in Civil War.

Canaan Fir - Abies balsamea var.phanerolepis - soft, short, bluish to dark green needles, one-half to one and one-fourth inches, needles silver on underside. Strong branches and open growing pattern. Good needle retention and fragrance.

Douglas Fir - Pseudotsuga menziesii - good fragrance; holds blue to dark green; one to one and one-half inch needles; needles have one of the best aromas among Christmas trees when crushed; branches are spreading and drooping. After being cut, the Douglas fir will last three to four weeks. Named after David Douglas who studied the tree in the 1800s; good conical shape; can live for a thousand years.

Fraser Fir - Abies fraseri - dark green, flattened needles; one half to one inch long; good needle retention; nice scent; pyramid-shaped, strong branches which turn upward. The Fraser fir was named for botanist John Fraser who explored the southern Appalachians in the late 1700’s.

Grand Fir - Adies grandis - shiny, dark green needles about one to one and one-half inches long; the needles, when crushed, give off a citrusy smell. Will last 3 to 4 weeks after being cut.

Noble Fir - Abies procera - one inch long, bluish-green needles with a silvery appearance; has short, stiff branches; great for heavier ornaments; keeps well; is used to make wreaths, door swags and garland. With good care the tree will last for six weeks after being cut.

Concolor Fir - Abies concolor - blue-green needles are one half to one and one-half inches long; nice shape and good aroma, a citrus scent; good needle retention. In nature the concolor fir can live to 350 years.

Austrian Fir - Pinus nigra - dark green needles, four to six inches long; retains needles well; moderate fragrance.

Red Pine - Pinus resinosa - dark green needles four to six inches long; big and bushy.

Scotch Pine - Pinus sylvestris - most common Christmas tree; stiff branches hold heavy ornaments well; stiff, dark green needles one inch long; holds needles for four weeks; needles will stay on even when dry; has open appearance and more room for ornaments; keeps aroma throughout the season; introduced into United States by European settlers.

Virginia Pine - Pinus virginiana - dark green needles are one and one half to three inches long in twisted pairs; strong branches enabling it to hold heavy ornaments; strong aromatic pine scent; a popular southern Christmas tree.

White Pine - Pinus strobus - soft, blue-green needles, two to five inches long in bundles of five; retains needles throughout the holiday season; very full appearance; little or no fragrance; less allergic reactions as compared to more fragrant trees; doesn’t hold heavy ornaments well. Largest pine in United States; state tree of Michigan and Maine; slender branches will support fewer and smaller decorations as compared to Scotch pine.

Black Hills Spruce - Pinus glauca var. densata - green to blue-green needles; one fourth to one third inch long; stiff needles may be difficult to handle for small children.

Blue Spruce - Picea pungens - dark green to powdery blue; very stiff needles, three-fourth to one and one-half inches long; good form; will drop needles in a warm room; symmetrical; but is best among species for needle retention; branches are stiff and will support many heavy decorations. The blue spruce is the state tree of Utah and Colorado, and it can live in nature 600 to 800 years.

Norway Spruce - Picea abies - needles one half to one inch long and shiny, dark green. Needle retention is poor without proper care; strong fragrance; nice conical shape. The Norway spruce is very popular in Europe.

White Spruce - Picea glauca - needles one half to three-fourth inch long; green to bluish green, short, stiff needles; crushed needles have an unpleasant odor; good needle retention. The white spruce is the state tree of South Dakota.

"After you’ve picked that "perfect" tree, follow these tips to keep your tree fresh throughout the holiday season," Wolford said.

If you are not putting the tree up right away, store it in an unheated garage or some other area out of the wind and cold (freezing) temperatures. Make a fresh one-inch cut on the butt end and place the tree in a bucket of warm water.

"When you decide to bring the tree indoors, make another fresh one inch cut and place the tree in a sturdy stand that holds at least one gallon of water, or a rule of thumb is one quart of water for every inch of diameter of the trunk," he said.

Be sure to keep the water level about the base of the tree. If the base dries out, resin will form over the cut end and the tree will not be able to absorb water and will dry out quickly. Commercially prepared mixes with aspirin, sugar and other additives added to the water are not necessary. Research has shown that plain water will keep a tree fresh.

"Check all Christmas tree lights for worn electrical cords," said Wolford. "Use UL-approved electrical decorations and cords. Unplug tree lights at night.

"Miniature lights produce less heat and reduce the drying effect on the tree. Or try the energy-efficient LED lights. LED lights use less energy and are more durable and longer lasting than incandescent Christmas lights."

Wolford recommended taking down the tree before it dries out. Many fresh cut trees if properly cared for will last at least three to five weeks before drying out.

"Recycle your tree after Christmas," he said. "Many communities will pick up trees and turn them into chips. You might also put the tree in your back yard and place bread and suet among the branches for the birds."

For more information, please check out the University of Illinois Extension web site Christmas Trees and More at www.urbanext.uiuc.edu/trees

 

 

 

Return to the Main Page